Here’s how stupid Colorado election rules are. We have five competent people running for attorney general and one incompetent one, and the incompetent one, Jena Griswold, probably will win. This would not happen with any sane system of voting. Maybe we’ll see a surprise, but the fact that Griswold has such strong odds illustrates the problems even if Michael Dougherty (most likely) overtakes her.
The first problem is that we split the primary into major-party ballots, so voters have to choose which party to engage with. That is stupid and wrong (as I wrote last time). We need a unified primary ballot that takes no notice of party.
The second problem is that, in a crowded field, a candidate can win with support from a small minority of voters even if another candidate is more broadly preferred.
In this case, the Democratic primary includes Griswold, Dougherty, Hetal Doshi, and David Seligman. Hence, Griswold theoretically can win with only 25%-plus-one support of voters who participate in the Democratic primary. She could win even if 75%-minus-one of voters prefer anyone other than Griswold for the office. That’s ridiculous!
Here’s how approval voting would solve the problem. Anyone who preferred anyone other than Griswold could vote for (approve of) all the other candidates. And anyone who (inexplicably) preferred Griswold also could vote for their second-choice candidate (and third-choice if they wanted). So approval voting would be much more likely to select a candidate with broader appeal, even if not the first choice of most voters.
Ranked-choice voting would be better than what we have now, but it is subject to weird outcomes in certain cases. Let’s say Candidate A is either everyone’s first choice or close second choice, and most voters would be happy if Candidate A won. Under approval voting, Candidate A does well. Under ranked-choice voting, Candidate A can get eliminated in the first round. For example, if Candidate A got 24% of first-choice votes, Candidates B and C got 25% each, and Candidate D got 26%, Candidate A would be eliminated. So that, plus the fact that it’s way easier to understand and implement on the ballot, is why I favor approval voting.
Griswold’s opponents slam her
Recently 9News’s Kyle Clark interviewed candidates for attorney general. Griswold declined to participate. But, while I was watching the segment on YouTube, a Griswold ad played, illustrating Griswold’s spend-big strategy.
In another set of clips, Griswold’s opponents slammed her. Clark asked about Griswold falsely claiming to argue before the Supreme Court. He asked if Griswold is qualified for the office. Unsurprisingly, her opponents had little nice to say about her. Dougherty said bluntly that Griswold is not qualified, having “never once handled a case in the state of Colorado.”
Clark also asked Dougherty: “You also understand how math works. And, while you, and David Seligman, and Hetal Doshi have raised concerns about Jena Griswold’s qualifications to be attorney general, you also know that the fact that all three of you are in this race practically guarantees that she’s going to be the next attorney general. Are you all putting your own personal ambition over the state having a qualified attorney general?”
Dougherty answered no. The obvious answer is yes. But the real problem is that our stupid voting rules allow for such absurd outcomes.
Voting rules are not a law of nature. We can change them! And, obviously, we should.
Griswold’s campaign stinks
This CBS headline indicates the problems with the race: “Colorado Secretary of State and AG candidate Jena Griswold misleads voters about an outhouse and more.”
Griswold told voters, “I grew up in a cabin with an outhouse outside on food stamps.” Yes, her house did have an outhouse, which Griswold says she used sometimes. But her house also had indoor plumbing. As they say, half the truth is a great lie.
In her time as Secretary of State, Griswold also was involved in controversies involving leaked voting-system passwords, high staff turnover, and, as CPR reports, “accidentally mailed postcards [about voter registration] to roughly 30,000 non-citizens.”
That Griswold is the most likely candidate to win the attorney general race is ridiculous. Maybe we’ll get lucky this time and our idiotic voting rules won’t result in the election of the least-competent candidate. But the fact that such an outcome is a very real possibility shows that it’s well past time for sensible reforms.
Ari Armstrong writes regularly for Complete Colorado and is the author of books about Ayn Rand, Harry Potter, and classical liberalism. He can be reached at ari at ariarmstrong dot com.

