Complete Colorado

Complaint accuses ‘CoCo’ rail district of tax-funded advocacy

STERLING – An eastern Colorado resident who was courted by the Front Range Passenger Rail District (FRPR) to be one of its “CoCo Conductors,” has filed a campaign finance complaint with the secretary of state’s office, saying that FRPR’s contention that millions of dollars in paid advertising supporting the newly formed Colorado Connector (CoCo) passenger rail line was not advocacy is simply not true.

At issue, according to Cory Gaines–who brought the complaint–is $500,000 of taxpayer money spent on three mailers targeting just 246,000 households, a small fraction of the taxing area that CoCo rail line would cover, $192,000 spend on Google and You Tube ads, and hundreds of thousands more for Meta and TikTok ads.

In fact, Gains points to a Denverite article that found FRPR spent nearly $2 million total in “positive advertising” to targeted groups to support the taxpayer funded passenger rail that would serve 12 communities across Northern Colorado.

“FRPR violated campaign finance law by violating parts of the Colorado Fair Campaign Practices Act, using taxpayer money for advocacy,” the complaint says in part, “as well as by not including proper disclosures on electioneering materials this close to an election.”

Promotional blitz ahead of tax hike

FRPR spent the money on a blitz campaign in favor of the passenger rail line in August, just three months before the November election, where voters from Pueblo to Fort Collins are being asked to approve a regional tax hike to support the project.

The FRPR board referred the .333 percent sales tax, numbered Ballot Issue 7A, to Front Range voters in late August.

The money for the promotional blitz came almost entirely from the Regional Transportation District (RTD), which pledged $3 million from its coffers in funding for “outreach” for the project.

According to the Denverite article, CoCo “paid social-media creators on Instagram and TikTok an undisclosed portion of an overall $1.3 million media-buying budget for the campaign. Influencers repeated talking points aligned with the government-funded campaign,” yet failed to disclose that they were paid for their effort. “It also targeted ads to specific groups online — one video, for example, was aimed at women whose households earn more than $100,000.”

Just swampy, or against the law?

Gaines, who is also a contributing writer to Complete Colorado, said after he wrote a May 4 post about CoCo going to RTD for money in his Colorado Accountability Project substack, CoCo staff emailed him and asked if he would like to be one of their influencers, coined a “CoCo Conductor.”

He never imagined what that would become.

Sal Pace, general manager of the Front Range Passenger Rail District, told Denverite it was not advocacy.

“It was critically important that we have an educational component with all of the communications, not only because it’s our statutory responsibility to stay educational but also to retain the trust of the constituents,” he said.

But Gaines said he doesn’t buy it, adding just because you call it educational, doesn’t make it so.

“What makes this go from merely swampy to violating the law is the use of public money to pay social media influencers for what are essentially political ads in support of their ballot measure,” Gaines told Complete Colorado. “It also lies in their choosing to not require their influencers (or themselves) to disclose their ballot issue spending.

According to Gaines, FRPR seems to “have conveniently forgotten how social media works,” meaning the posts don’t simply disappear. “Even if they cut off the money to the influencers prior to putting the tax issue on the ballot, what they paid for lives on right up to the election, with little to no disclosure to voters.”

“If they chose this, they should have to register their pieces as electioneering as we’d expect from anyone else,” said Gaines.

The complaint is available here.

SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM

Our unofficial motto at Complete Colorado is “Always free, never fake, ” but annoyingly enough, our reporters, columnists and staff all want to be paid in actual US dollars rather than our preferred currency of pats on the back and a muttered kind word. Fact is we have an entire staff working every day to bring you the most timely and relevant political news (updated twice daily) aggregated from around the state, as well as top-notch original reporting and commentary.

PLEASE SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM AND LADLE A LITTLE GRAVY ON THE CREW AT COMPLETE COLORADO. You’ll be giving to Independence Institute, the not-for-profit publisher of Complete Colorado, which makes your donation tax deductible. But rest assured that your giving will go specifically to the Complete Colorado news operation. Thanks for being a Complete Colorado reader, keep coming back.

LATEST VIDEOS

SUPPORT OUR SPONSOR

LATEST PODCASTS